Customers look at milk in a supermarket in Beijing
Monday Nov. 24, 2008. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration last week
opened an office in Beijing, days after U.S. health officials detained
foods from China made with milk and other dairy ingredients as a
precaution to keep out foods contaminated with melamine. Dairy products
tainted with the industrial chemical melamine have been blamed in the
deaths of at least three babies in China, while tens of thousands of
other children were sickened
Public health groups, consumer advocates and members of Congress blasted the Food and Drug Administration
yesterday for failing to act after discovering trace amounts of the
industrial chemical melamine in baby formula sold in the United States.
"This FDA, this Bush administration, instead of protecting the public health, is protecting industry," said Rep. Rosa DeLauro
(D-Conn.), who chairs the Appropriations subcommittee that oversees the
FDA budget. In an interview, DeLauro said she wants the agency to
disclose its findings and to develop a plan to remove melamine from
formula. "We're talking about babies, about the most vulnerable. This
really makes me angry."
The FDA found melamine and cyanuric acid, a related chemical, in
samples of baby formula made by major U.S. manufacturers. Melamine can
cause kidney and bladder stones and, in worst cases, kidney failure and
death. If melamine and cyanuric acid combine, they can form round
yellow crystals that can also damage kidneys and destroy renal
function.
Melamine was found in Good Start Supreme Infant Formula With Iron made by Nestle,
and cyanuric acid was detected in Enfamil Lipil With Iron infant
formula powder made by Mead Johnson. A spokesman for Nestle did not
respond to repeated calls and e-mails for comment yesterday.
Gail Wood, a spokeswoman for Mead Johnson, said the company does not
think that cyanuric acid poses a health threat to infants. "Cyanuric
acid is approved by the FDA to sanitize processing equipment," she
said. "The risks of not sanitizing equipment are far greater than ultra
trace amounts of residual cyanuric acid found in the formula."
The FDA has been testing hundreds of food products for melamine in
the aftermath of a scandal this year involving Chinese infant formula
tainted with melamine. Chinese manufacturers deliberately added the
chemical to watered-down formula to make it appear to contain higher
levels of protein. More than 50,000 Asian infants were hospitalized,
and at least four died.
The FDA collected 87 samples of infant formula made by American
manufacturers, tested all but 10 of them and held a conference call
Monday with manufacturers to alert them to the preliminary findings,
FDA spokeswoman Judy Leon said. She said she did not know when the
agency was planning to inform the public.
The test results were unearthed by the Associated Press, which had filed a request for records under the Freedom of Information Act.
Leon said that the amounts discovered are safe and that parents
should continue to feed formula to their children. "We know that trace
levels do not pose a risk whatsoever," she said.
That contradicts the agency's recent statements about melamine,
including a position paper that was on its Web site yesterday that
asserted there are no safe levels of melamine for infants. "FDA is
currently unable to establish any level of melamine and
melamine-related compounds in infant formula that does not raise public
health concerns," the document said.
Agency scientists have maintained they could not set a safe level of
melamine exposure for babies because they do not understand the effects
of long-term exposure on a baby's developing kidneys. The problem is
exacerbated by the fact that infant formula is a baby's sole source of
food for many months. Premature infants absorb an especially large dose
of the chemical, compared with full-term babies.
"Just one month ago, the FDA had been very clear about how they
could not set a safe level of melamine in formula for babies," said
Sonya Lunder, a senior analyst at the Environmental Working Group, an advocacy organization. "Now they're saying trace levels are no problem. What changed?"